by Shia LaBeouf’s Transformers films were box office hits, but here’s why he did not return as Sam Witwicky in Transformer 4: Age of Extinction. Shia LaBeouf played the human hero Sam Witwicky in the first three installments of the Transformers franchise, but did not return for Transformers 4: Age of Extinction or its sequels — so why was this the case? The original Transformers trilogy, directed by Michael Bay, was LaBeouf’s first outing as the lead of a blockbuster movie, but he was already a familiar face to audiences having starred in Disney’s Even Stevens. Although he left the franchise in 2011, the Transformers films are still among LaBeouf’s best performances at the box office — but the movie’s commercial success has not been enough to keep him interested in returning to the franchise.
~
~
The first Transformers movie saw Shia LeBeouf begin his role as the franchise’s human lead, Sam Witwicky, working with the heroic Autobots to protect the Earth from being destroyed by the Decepticons. While this role would be reprised in Transformers 2: Revenge of the Fallen and Transformers 3: Dark of the Moon, Sam does not feature in the later sequels, which naturally raised plenty of questions as to where the character had ended up. This seemed especially weird to some audiences, as Witwicky had gone from the main character in the series to a figure who is only briefly alluded to in Transformers 5 — and even then, only to suggest he died off-screen sometime between the films. However, put simply, Shia LaBeouf didn’t return in Transformers 4 because he felt Sam’s story was over with the completion of the initial trilogy. While promoting Dark of The Moon, LaBeouf confirmed (via MTV) that he was leaving the franchise, saying “I just don’t think there’s anywhere to take it with Sam”. Many felt the character of Sam Witwicky had grown stale by Transformers 3.
~
~
The likable nerd-turned-hero from the first installment was hindered by a lack of character development in the sequels and ended up regularly complaining about not working closely with the Autobots. Shia LaBeouf has also been outspoken about the Transformers film’s lack of purpose. In a 2018 interview (via Esquire) he described the films as “irrelevant” compared to more grounded stories. LaBeouf’s acting credits following his departure from Transformers 4 proves that he is motivated to be part of more relatable stories which do not rely on CGI effects and roles that grant him creative freedom, such as his performances in the acclaimed Honey Boy. As for Transformers, the franchise has continued to be a success without LaBeouf. Transformers 4, the series’ highest-grossing film, replaces Sam with Mark Wahlberg’s Cade Yeager, who teams up with the Autobots to defeat Lockdown, a bounty hunting Transformer chasing Optimus Prime.
~
~
The series also introduced a Bumblebee spin-off that shares similarities to the original Transformers and is considered the best Transformers film by many critics. The franchise is set to continue to grow without LaBeouf, with a Bumblebee sequel in development. While he didn’t appear in Transformers 4, given Shia LaBeouf’s star power and his importance to the series, he’s not entirely out of the running for future installments — though the franchise would have to qualify why he isn’t dead should he appear any time after Transformers 5. Both Wahlberg’s Cade Yeager and LaBeouf’s Sam Witwicky have their strengths and weaknesses — but which character is better? A key criticism of the Transformers franchise is its lack of intelligent and dynamic female characters, as well as Witwicky and Yeager’s treatment of them. After the first Transformers film, the quality of the writing arguably took a downward turn, adding legitimacy to LaBeouf’s excuse for leaving. While Sam Witwicky was a great character, he was made worse whenever he had a love interest.
~
~
Starting in Transformers 2, Witwicky became cockier, more arrogant, and more inclined to take people for granted, especially when it came to his treatment of Carly. Cade Yeager faced similar problems in his treatment of his daughter, who spends most of Transformers 4: Age of Extinction occupying a damsel-in-distress role. His character did manage to poke fun at Witwicky’s machismo as displayed in the previous three movies, but it wasn’t really enough to strike up a favorable comparison. Ultimately, the complaints that Yeager was the same as Sam Witwicky, but older, held weight – the main Transformers movies never really had a lead to match the stature and impact of the Autobots, and neither Witwicky nor Yeager had the long-term charisma the franchise needed. Shia LaBeouf was fully justified in making good his escape from the character and franchise.
